Exploring Package Validation Testing for Temperature-Controlled Shipping
Temperature validation testing plays a critical role in ensuring the integrity and safety of products during transit, particularly for items that require strict temperature control, such as those in the life sciences industry. This article will delve into package validation testing, its significance, and the industries that rely on it. We’ll also discuss the importance of temperature modeling and the improvements that can be made to enhance the performance of cold chain packages.
Understanding Temperature Validation
Temperature validation testing, often associated with cold chain package testing, is vital in the supply chain, ensuring that products maintain the required temperature tolerance throughout their journey. This process starts from manufacturing and continues through distribution and storage, concluding with delivery to the customer. Failure to maintain proper temperature control can result in compromised product integrity, which can be catastrophic, particularly in industries like life sciences and food.
Types of Packages Tested
Temperature validation can be applied to various package types, including single units, multiple packed units, entire pallets, or containers. When testing multiple units, temperature mapping is essential to identify potential weaknesses. Larger quantities, such as pallets, may present challenges due to variations in external conditions. The position within the load, exposure to the sun, and even overpacking can affect the temperature differently. To address these issues, data loggers and thermocouple systems are used for evaluation, and both hot and cold temperature conditions may be applied during cold chain verification.
Contact us today for a quote.
Industries That Require Temperature Validation
Temperature validation is a crucial concern in various industries, but it is more prevalent in some, such as the food and pharmaceutical industries. In the food industry, frozen food package testing is essential to ensure products remain frozen during transit. Any deviation from the required temperature can lead to quality issues. In the pharmaceutical industry, the challenges are even greater, as medicines must avoid becoming too warm and cold. Cold chain modeling for pharmaceutical products involves meticulous attention to temperature control.
Use Case Example: COVID-19 Vaccine Distribution
A real-world example of the critical importance of temperature validation testing is the distribution of COVID-19 vaccines. Like the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, these vaccines must be stored at ultra-low temperatures, typically around -70 degrees Celsius. Any deviation from this temperature range can render the vaccines ineffective.
Temperature validation testing played a central role in the global distribution of these vaccines. At every stage of the supply chain, from manufacturing to distribution, pharmaceutical companies and logistics providers used specialized packaging, refrigeration, and monitoring systems to ensure that the vaccines remained within the specified temperature range. Regular temperature validation testing was conducted to confirm that the vaccines were not compromised during transit.
Temperature Modeling
To conduct temperature validation effectively, it is essential to understand the distribution environment through data collection. Thermocouple probes and data loggers record the package’s response to different conditions. The data should cover all seasons and various shipping routes, considering external conditions. This data helps identify areas of weakness and temperature excursions, which must be addressed to eliminate failures.
Improvements to Cold Chain Packages
Various strategies can be employed to enhance the performance of cold chain packages. Using insulated shipping containers and specialty containers when needed is crucial. Refrigerator trucks, reefer ships, and reefer containers are the most common vehicles used for temperature-controlled transport. Warehouses should also have temperature control to maintain product integrity. The choice of packaging material is essential, balancing performance and cost.
Various strategies can be employed to enhance the performance of cold chain packages. Using insulated shipping containers and specialty containers when needed is crucial. Refrigerator trucks, reefer ships, and reefer containers are the most common vehicles used for temperature-controlled transport. Warehouses should also have temperature control to maintain product integrity. The choice of packaging material is essential, balancing performance and cost.
40 Years Experience
green solutions
cost-effective
In-House Support
lab services
global manufacturing
Package Testing
Our ISTA standard 20 certified thermal testing lab can provide expert guidance and testing services for businesses looking to validate their packages for temperature-controlled shipping. We understand the importance of temperature transit testing and can help companies avoid product launch delays.
Here are some of the testing types that may be requested:
- Temperature Mapping: Temperature mapping involves placing temperature sensors (data loggers or thermocouples) inside the packaging to monitor temperature variations during transit and storage. This test helps identify potential hot or cold spots within the package.
- Cold Chain Verification: Cold chain verification tests the packaging’s ability to maintain the specified temperature range, particularly in cold chain logistics. This includes both refrigerated and frozen temperature conditions.
- Thermal Shock Testing: Thermal shock testing assesses the packaging’s resilience to sudden and extreme temperature changes. This test is particularly important for products that may experience rapid temperature fluctuations during transportation.
- Accelerated Aging: Accelerated aging testing simulates the effects of prolonged storage and transportation on the packaging and the temperature-sensitive product. It helps assess the long-term integrity of the packaging under varying temperature conditions.
- Dye Penetration Test: This test determines the packaging’s ability to prevent the ingress of external contaminants or moisture. It assesses the integrity of seals and closures, ensuring the packaging remains leak-free.
- Peel Strength Test: The peel strength test evaluates the bonding strength of seals and closures. It ensures the packaging maintains its integrity, even under stress or pressure.
- Bubble Emission Test: The bubble emission test assesses the packaging for any leakage or seal defects. It uses pressurized air or a similar method to detect any gas or liquid leakage from the packaging.
- Visual Inspection: Visual inspection involves a detailed visual examination of the packaging for any visible defects, damage, or irregularities that could compromise its performance.
- Burst Test: The burst test measures the packaging’s resistance to pressure. It determines the point at which the packaging may rupture or fail when exposed to pressure conditions.
- Creep Test: The creep test assesses the packaging’s deformation or elongation under a sustained load. It helps determine how well the packaging maintains its structural integrity over time.
- ASTM F1886: This test evaluates the packaging’s ability to resist microbial contamination, such as bacteria or mold, by exposing it to specific conditions that promote microbial growth.
Conclusion
Temperature validation testing is critical in temperature-controlled shipping, ensuring that products maintain their required temperature tolerances throughout the supply chain. Industries like food and pharmaceuticals rely on this testing to guarantee product integrity. By collecting data, conducting temperature modeling, and making necessary improvements to packaging and logistics, companies can ensure the safety and effectiveness of their products during transit.
Contact our ISTA-certified thermal testing lab to discuss your needs and receive expert guidance if you require package validation testing.
